In The Zone is out now on the App Store — iPhone & Apple Watch. Get it for $1.99 →

The blog

The problem with starting again is that you remember last time

Starting for the first time has one advantage nobody mentions while it is happening: you have no record. There is nothing to consult. You do not yet know what you tend to do around week three, so you can go out on a Monday with a reasonably open mind about how the whole thing will turn out.

Starting again is a different business. By the third or fourth attempt you have accumulated evidence, you have read all of it, and the conclusion you have drawn is not a kind one. You know how this goes. You have watched yourself do it. The shoes are in the cupboard from last time and they are barely worn, which tells its own story every time you open the door.

What you think the record proves

People who have stopped a few times tend to arrive at the same verdict on themselves. Not that the plan was wrong, or that the timing was poor. That they are the sort of person who does not finish things. It gets filed as a fact about character rather than a description of some weeks that went badly.

It is worth being precise about what happened, because the character version skips all the detail. Go back and look at each stop on its own. One of them was an illness that took a fortnight, and afterwards you never quite picked it up again. Another was a stretch at work that took everything you had and left nothing for the evening. At least one was a plan that had you out five mornings a week, which almost nobody keeps, and which you were always going to fall out of. Four different weeks in a life, then, rather than the same event happening four times to the same defective person.

The gap between stopping and failing

Stopping gets treated as the end of an attempt, when it is usually closer to a pause that ran on longer than you meant it to. Nothing was cancelled. Nobody revoked your permission to go out again. The only thing that actually ended was the streak, and the streak was a scoring system you invented and then used against yourself.

The same is true of the gap that follows. A month off does not undo the work that came before it, and it does not require an apology or a fresh declaration to end. You can simply go out again on an ordinary evening, without announcing anything, and let the gap be a gap.

You do not have to believe in yourself first

The advice you will hear is to want it more, or to find your reason, or to get your head right before your feet. That puts the hardest part first and makes it a condition of entry. If you have to feel convinced before you go, and the previous attempts have quietly removed your ability to feel convinced, you will be standing at the door for a long time.

Belief is not the entry fee. You can go out this evening while privately expecting to stop again in a month. The run does not ask what you think of yourself before it lets you do it, and thirty minutes of moving works exactly the same whether you did it in hope or in doubt.

Small promises, kept where you can see them

Trust in yourself comes back through a short run of things you said you would do and then did, kept small enough that the saying and the doing sit close together. Fifteen minutes on Wednesday. Not a programme, not a return to form, not a new version of you. Fifteen minutes, on Wednesday, and then it is Wednesday and you go.

Do that a few times and something quiet happens to the evidence. You now have entries that point the other way. They look unimpressive written down, and they are the only sort of proof that has ever changed anybody's mind about themselves.

Something else survived the earlier attempts, too. You know which week is usually the one where it slips. You have learned, at some cost, that going out too fast on the first day makes the second day worse. You can recognise your own favourite excuse while it is still being assembled, which is more than most people managing their first month can do.

So the record exists. Read it as a list of the times you wanted this enough to begin, which is not nothing, and which the version in your head leaves out entirely.

Then go and do fifteen minutes on Wednesday.

Written to encourage, not to diagnose. If something hurts or feels wrong, please speak to a doctor.

Paul Zarou is a leadership coach and the author of six books on compassion and resilience. He writes here about the parts of training nobody puts on a highlight reel. grcsac.com